Loading...
Loading...

Police pull over a woman who claims she just gave birth. But the baby โ and the blood โ aren't hers. Twisted lies unravel in this true-crime documentary.
Maternal Instinct is a 2026 Netflix true crime documentary directed by Jessica Dimmock, which premiered on 12 June 2026. It revisits a case from October 2020 in New Boston, Texas, and it opens the way the case itself began: with a woman being pulled over for speeding by a state trooper, holding a bloodied newborn, insisting to both the officer and the 911 dispatcher that she had given birth in her car only minutes before. Body-cam footage makes it apparent within seconds that this is not what happened. What actually happened is considerably worse.
The woman was Taylor Rene Parker, then twenty-seven. For months she had been faking a pregnancy, sustaining the deception with a silicone belly and an invented story about a multi-million dollar inheritance, maintaining it in front of her boyfriend Wade Griffin, her family and her entire community. She could not have been pregnant, having previously undergone a hysterectomy. Accounts from those around her suggest Griffin was withdrawing from the relationship, and the lies escalated in response.
When the deception ran out of room, Parker murdered her friend Reagan Simmons-Hancock, a twenty-one-year-old mother who was more than eight months pregnant, and removed her unborn child before fleeing with the infant, who did not survive. Parker was convicted and sentenced to death, and remains on death row.
I have watched a considerable amount of true crime for this channel at this point, and I want to state plainly that it takes a profound and specific kind of evil to do that to somebody you called a friend.
The question the film leaves you circling is how nobody stopped it, and the answer is the detail that has stayed with me longer than anything else. Multiple hospitals in the New Boston area already knew. They knew Parker had undergone a hysterectomy. They knew she was publicly claiming to be pregnant. And they knew she had already attempted to take a baby from a medical facility. Because of patient confidentiality obligations, none of them were in a position to communicate any of this to anybody outside their own walls. The information existed. It was simply locked in the wrong rooms.
I want to be careful about the people who believed her, because it would be easy to be harsh here and I do not think it is fair. Several people around her were suspicious, said so, and deserve real credit for it. But those she convinced were being worked by somebody running a sustained, physically elaborate deception with props and paperwork. That is not gullibility. That is being targeted by a practised manipulator.
Do you agree with this review?
Reviewed on September 9, 2026
The most difficult passage of the film, by a distance, concerns Reagan's mother, Jessica. She went to her daughter's house that morning because Reagan had not dropped her three-year-old granddaughter at daycare. She found the garage door open. She found a bloody footprint. And then she found her daughter. Her 911 call is included in the documentary, and I do not have adequate words for it. There is no worse sound in the world than a parent who has just lost a child. Jessica later describes the loss as being like losing part of her own body, and that is the closest anybody in this film gets to articulating it. Reagan's stepfather Marcus and a family friend, Chris, also speak, and a great deal of care has clearly been taken with all three of them.
If I have a criticism, it is structural. The documentary does not interview a single police officer, investigator or attorney connected to the case, which is a genuinely unusual choice for the genre. In fairness, the sequence of events here is so stark that expert framing is barely required, and the existing case footage, including officers questioning Parker at the hospital, carries most of the necessary weight. Still, their absence is noticeable.
This is a well-made and, importantly, a respectful documentary about an appalling crime. It centres Reagan's family rather than her killer, which is the right decision and one the genre does not always make.
7 out of 10. Recommended, but be prepared to sit there saying what on earth, repeatedly, and go gently with yourself afterwards.
The Verdict
6/10 โ Recommended
1996
Streaming on ยท US